Timothy ferguson case pictures

In the Timothy Ferguson case, the use of "Timothy Ferguson pictures" played a pivotal role in shedding light on the horrific abuse that the young boy had endured. These visual records served as compelling evidence that vividly illustrated the extent of Timothy's suffering. The photographs captured his emaciated and bruised body, providing ...

Timothy ferguson case pictures. MUSKEGON, Mich. (AP) — A jury on Friday found a western Michigan woman guilty of murder and child abuse in the starvation death of her disabled 15-year-old son who weighed just 69 pounds.. The Muskegon County Circuit Court jury deliberated just over an hour before convicting Shanda Vander Ark, 44, of Norton Shores in the July 6, 2022, death of Timothy Ferguson.

See more videos about Timothy Ferguson Images, Timothy Ferguson Pics, Actual Autopsy Pictures, Twice Las Vegas Price 2024, Cat Reacting to Jack Harlow, 10 Minute Video Asmr Full Video Talking. ... Timothy died of a combination of malnourishment and hypothermia, with prosecutors saying it's the 'most disturbing case' they've seen in ...

Feb 26, 2024 · The judge said: "Mr. Ferguson is trying to shift blame from him to his mother and say that somehow, if it wasn't for her, I wouldn't have done this, or she's the one that did this." During Vander Ark's court case, prosecutor Matt Roberts showed pictures of Timothy's 69lb body to the jury and the mum, causing her to be sick. With Post wires. Filed under. child abuse. crime. michigan. murders. 12/17/23. Shanda Vander Ark, 44, vomited on the stand after seeing photos of teen son Timothy Ferguson's malnourished body ...Overall, the Timothy Ferguson Michigan Photo collection is a difficult and distressing set of images that depict a tragic case of child abuse and neglect. While ...Dec 22, 2023 · Paul Ferguson pleaded guilty to first-degree child abuse Thursday in the death of his brother, 15-year-old Timothy Ferguson. This comes a week after Paul and Timothy's mother, Shanda Vander Ark ... Jan 23, 2024 · Shanda Vander Ark is guilty of the 2022 murder of her 15-year-old son Timothy Ferguson, the jury determined in about an hour of deliberation on Dec. 15. Vander Ark was convicted of open murder and ... Shanda Vander Ark, 44, was on trial for torturing her disabled 15-year-old son Timothy Ferguson at their home in Michigan, USA. During the hearing, prosecutor Matt Roberts showed pictures of ... Timothy Ferguson had some mental disabilities and was being home-schooled, prosecutors have said. Vander Ark's older son, Paul Ferguson, 21, has also been charged in the case.Pictures of Timothy Ferguson's lifeless body shown in court showed bruises and his ribs nearly visible through his skin. Timothy Ferguson had some mental disabilities and was instead being home ...

Jan 23, 2024 ... "I want the world to know that Timothy was wanted. If not by her, then by me. He was loved by me," Millie Ferguson said at Shanda Vander ...Published 10:28 AM PDT, August 8, 2019. FERGUSON, Mo. (AP) — On Aug. 9, 2014, Michael Brown and a friend were walking in the middle of Canfield Drive, a two-lane street in the St. Louis suburb of Ferguson, Missouri, when a police officer drove by and told them to use the sidewalk. After words were exchanged, the white officer confronted the ...Vander Ark, 43, and Paul Ferguson, 20, are alleged to have tortured Timothy Ferguson in various ways that contributed to the boy’s death. Timothy was autistic as well and speech and motor ...Timothy John Ferguson, 48, pleaded guilty in a negotiated plea deal June 6 before Chief Superior Court Judge Arch McGarity to regarding original charges of incest, child molestation and aggravated ...16.8M views. Discover videos related to Timothy Ferguson Picture on TikTok. See more videos about Timothy Ferguson Images, Timothy Ferguson Pics, Popup Bagels Spoilers, Stradegy for Digsite Pet Sim 99, Christian Talks Abt How Elf on The Shelf Is Evil, Crofton Microwave Bakewave.Timothy Ferguson Pictures. The heart-breaking event of the life of a fifteen-year-old boy, Timothy Ferguson, died under alarming circumstances. The dreadful revelation of his self-possessed state, wearing zip ties and chains. The autopsy report mentioned that skipped meals for several months have left the public in Norton Shores contending with ...@CrimeTok Shanda Sander Ark was found guilty of murdering her disabled son, 15-year-old Timothy Ferguson, whom she tortured and starved. Ark only fed him hot sauce soaked bread, deprived him of sleep & and would force him into ice baths. The teenager, who had autism and motor impairments, was made to sleep in a closet under the stairs and it's reported in his dying moments, Ark clamped his ...

In a case that has sent shockwaves through Muskegon County, Michigan, Shanda Vander Ark faces grave charges for the torture and murder of her 15-year-old son, Timothy Ferguson. The appalling details of Timothy's suffering came to light following his untimely death in July 2022, leading to the arrest of both Shanda and her elder son, Paul ...Pictured in this undated photo is a young Timothy Ferguson. The photo was shown during Shanda Vander Ark's sentencing in Muskegon County Circuit Court on Tuesday, Jan. 23, 2024.Timothy Ferguson Case Pictures. Paul Ferguson. Timothy Ferguson Case Sentencing. Timothy Ferguson Trial. Timothyferguson Case. 8698. Likes. 350. Comments. 59. Shares. stayinformedalways00. 8698. 226.6K. Shanda Vander Ark was convicted of neglecting her 15 year old son Timothy Ferguson so severely he died in the basement of her home. She will be ...Which memorial do you think is a duplicate of Timothy Richard Ferguson (248980161)? We will review the memorials and decide if they should be merged. Learn more about merges. Memorial ID. ... Photos. For memorials with more than one photo, additional photos will appear here or on the photos tab.Shanda Vander Ark is accused of severely abusing her teenage son with special needs, who was in an ice bath for 9 hours before he was declared dead....

How long is 91b ait.

#BREAKING: Key witness Paul Ferguson, victim Timothy Ferguson's older brother, said his mother, #ShandaVanderArk, forced him to lock up Timothy's food, feed him bread soaked in hot sauce, keep him from taking his medicine, and give him ice baths.Shanda Vander Ark is serving a life sentence for torturing her 15-year-old son, Timothy Ferguson, to death. She is seeking to regain parental rights of her youngest child, who is 8.When the prosecutor showed Shanda Vander Ark photos of her 15-year-old son Timothy Ferguson severely malnourished, she got sick on the stand. Ultimately, the...Timothy Ferguson was 15 years old and weighed just 69 pounds when he died of malnutrition and hypothermia at the hands of his evil mother and brother. Mom Guilty in Starvation Death of 15-Year-Old Son, Who Weighed 69 Pounds When He Died Join Joseph Scott Morgan and Dave Mack as they describe how Timothy Ferguson …Paul Ferguson, 21, pleaded guilty in December to first-degree child abuse in the death of 15-year-old Timothy Ferguson. He was sentenced Monday to a minimum of 30 years and a maximum of 100 years ...

A Michigan jury deliberated for about an hour on Friday before returning a guilty verdict for a mother accused in the torture killing of her 15-year-old son. Shanda Vander Ark was found guilty of open murder and first degree child abuse in the death of Timothy Ferguson, WZZM reported. Timothy weighed 69 pounds when he died on July 6, 2022, in a ...Norton Shores mom accused of torturing, killing son faced 'similar allegations' in custody case. Shanda Vander Ark, then Shanda Ferguson, voluntarily surrendered custody in 2012, court documents ...46.3M views. Discover videos related to Timothy Ferguson Pictures Right Before Death on TikTok. See more videos about Clinique Take The Day Off Cleansing Balm Discontinued, Kumemoj Lyrics Meaning, Pros and Cons of A Universal Basic Income for Every Canadian, 1 De Enero 2024 Aumento De Salario En Canada, Andrea Brillantes …Paul Ferguson, 21, pleaded guilty in December to first-degree child abuse in the death of 15-year-old Timothy Ferguson. He was sentenced Monday to a minimum of 30 years and a maximum of 100 years ...15M views. Discover videos related to Timothy Ferguson Pictures Texts on TikTok. See more videos about The Pictures on Her Phone, Georgia Stanway Football, Describing Me with Pictures, Answer The Phone Take A Picture Matrix, Messi Picture with His Wife, Irish Men Taking Pictures.68.7M visualizzazioni. Scopri i video relativi a Timothy Ferguson Death Photos su TikTok. Guarda altri video su Timothy Ferguson Photos Caso, Timothy Ferguson Death Video, Timothy Ferguson Pics Crime, Timothy Ferguson Crime Pics, Timothy Treadwell Death Photo, Timothy Ferguson Photos Tub.They found Shanda Vander Ark guilty of both first-degree murder and first-degree child abuse in the death of her 15-year-old son, Timothy Ferguson. The jury got the case just after 2:35 p.m ...Shanda Vander Ark Case: Prosecutor briefly shows photo of Timothy Ferguson taken by Paul Ferguson. This photo was sent to SVA along with a text request that Timothy be fed. ... I’ve just watched the court case and it’s so disturbing. I found her on fb and there’s pictures of Timothy with his brother Paul and G. A sweet happy boy who went ...Timothy Ferguson. Content note: Case narratives include descriptions of severe violence inflicted on children, including abuse and neglect, sexual violence, torture, and murder, as well as mentions of suicide and domestic violence. They also include photos of victims and perpetrators of violence. Case narrative.12.3M views. Discover videos related to Timothyferguson Video Footage on TikTok. See more videos about Actual Autopsy Pictures Timothy Ferguson, Timothy Ferguson Images, Timothy Ferguson Court Pictures, Timothy Ferguson Picture, Timothy Ferguson Home Video, Timothy Ferguson Body Cam.

Shanda Vander Ark was sentenced to life in prison with no chance at parole for torturing her 15-year-old son, Timothy Ferguson, to death.

Shanda Vander Ark,43, of Norton Shores, is facing open murder and first-degree child abuse charges in the death of Timothy Ferguson. Prosecutors say the medical examiner determined Ferguson died ...A 43-year-old Michigan mother is behind bars for allegedly starving and torturing her juvenile son to death, authorities say. Shanda Margaret Vander Ark was taken into custody last week and charged with one count each of open murder and first-degree child abuse in the death of 15-year-old Timothy Ferguson, court records reviewed by …841 Likes, 259 Comments. TikTok video from chaps (@chapisadime41): "REST IN LOVE TIMOTHY FERGUSON YOU ARE FREE AND JUSTICE IS SERVED 🙌🏼🙌🏼💙🕊️🙏🏻💙 #timothyferguson #shandavanderark #paulferguson #nortonshores #nortonshoresmi #michigan #michigancheck #fyp #justice #crime #xybca #xyzabc #truecrime #truecrimetiktok #truecrimecommunity #truecrimetok #heartbreaking # ... Discover videos related to home video of timothy ferguson on TikTok. See more videos about Reconsideration Sowp Latest, Chopara Sahib by Harjit Singh at Brampton, Stand Oil Oblong Bag Canada, Jahson Inmate Dating Canada, Temu Leak Unblur, Is Dr Ratio Worth It. "Beyond cruel." #ShandaVanderArk's son #PaulFerguson testified that his mother told ... Opinion. 68055-2-I. 02-19-2013. STATE OF WASHINGTON, Respondent, v. TIMOTHY LI-GEMINI FERGUSON, a/k/a TIMOTHY ROY Appellant. Lau, J. UNPUBLISHED OPINION. Lau, J. After a stipulated facts trial, the trial court convicted Timothy Ferguson of unlawful possession of cocaine with intent to deliver.Timothy Ferguson was a helpless 15-year-old boy with mental disabilities who weighed 69 pounds at the time of his death on July 6, and was restrained with zip …Go listen to their texts to each other while they abused Timothy-- Paul unable to help himself from losing it on Timothy and Shanda actually telling him to stop. Paul saying he wanted to "get rid of Timothy" and tightening his zip ties around his wrists and suggesting hotter hot sauce punishments. Paul ENJOYED hurting Timothy. He hated him.

Stormbringer manga.

Slo admission decision.

All posts of Timothy Ferguson's younger minor brother will be removed. The court protected his identity for a reason. Photos of victims and defendants are acceptable. But blur the faces of the other innocent siblings and NO photos of the minor child. 36.105.8K. 2.9M. Paul Ferguson, 21, pleaded guiltyto child abuse in the death of 15-year-old Timothy Ferguson, who was his disabled brother. He was sentenced Monday to a minimum of 30 years and a maximum of 100 years in prison. #paulferguson. fire.clip.12.3M views. Discover videos related to Timothyferguson Video Footage on TikTok. See more videos about Actual Autopsy Pictures Timothy Ferguson, Timothy Ferguson Images, Timothy Ferguson Court Pictures, Timothy Ferguson Picture, Timothy Ferguson Home Video, Timothy Ferguson Body Cam.The woman at the centre of the sexting scandal that prompted the resignation of former Australian Test cricket captain Tim Paine has filed a sexual harassment claim against Cricket Tasmania in the ...The case started when Timothy Ferguson was found dead July 6, 2022, at the Vander Ark family home in Norton Shores. The teen, who had autism and was speech- and motor-impaired, weighed only 69 ...Discover videos related to Paul Ferguson Full Case on TikTok. See more videos about Paul Alexanders Body Now, Nicholas Allen Case Explained, Reddington Court Case 10, Luke and Lewis Smith Case, Andrew Gosden Case, James Allen Case. ... Timothy Ferguson Case Pictures. Timothy Ferguson Autopsy. Timothy Ferguson Case Sentencing. Home Video of ...A Michigan man who pleaded guilty in his disabled brother's starvation death was sentenced Monday to a minimum of 30 years in prison by a judge who said the defendant is "one step away from becoming a psychopath." Paul Ferguson, 21, pleaded guilty in December to first-degree child abuse in the death of 15-year-old Timothy Ferguson. Timothy Ferguson, who had autism and was speech- and motor ...The case of Timothy Ferguson and the photos of his emaciated body served as a stark reminder of the importance of protecting children from abuse and neglect. In conclusion, the discovery of the photos of Timothy Ferguson's emaciated body during his mother's trial sparked public interest and media coverage. The images were so disturbing that ...Shanda Vander Ark, 44, of Norton Shores, found guilty in the July 6, 2022, death of Timothy Ferguson, was sentenced to an additional 50 to 100 years in prison for first-degree child abuse. ….

Ferguson, 21, was sentenced this week to a minimum 30 years in prison on a first-degree child abuse charge stemming from the torture and starvation death of 15-year-old Timothy Ferguson.Timothy Ferguson Deputy Assistant Director, Criminal Justice Information Services Division, Operational Programs Branch, Federal Bureau of InvestigationSee more videos about Actual Autopsy Pictures Timothy Ferguson, Timothy Ferguson Images, Timothy Ferguson Picture, Picture of Body, R Rated Pics, Actual Autopsy Pictures. ... Timothy Ferguson Case part 2 #timothyferguson #justicefortimothyferguson #truecrimetiktok #truecrime #shandavanderarkarrest #shandavanderark. original sound - Can't Sleep ...Timothy Ferguson’s disability. Timothy Ferguson, a bright spark despite his autism, faced unique challenges in a household where homeschooling became the norm.With his older brother, Paul, juggling the roles of both a high schooler and a caregiver, and his mother, Shana Vander Ark, shouldering the family’s financial burdens, Timothy’s upbringing was anything but ordinary.Paul Ferguson entered a guilty plea in court on Thursday afternoon, just two days after his mother, Shanda Vander Ark, was convicted of the murder of her disabled 15-year-old son, Timothy.On Friday, December 15, 2023, Shanda Vander Ark went on trial for the crimes of child abuse, murder and torturing her crippled 15-year-old son, Timothy Ferguson. During the trial, Vander Ark claimed that she gave her son a warm bath on the night he died. But her older son ” Paul Ferguson” disputed the claim.Check out production photos, hot pictures, movie images of Tim Ferguson and more from Rotten Tomatoes' celebrity gallery!Timothy Ferguson was a remarkable individual whose presence left an indelible mark on the lives of all who knew him. Known for his infectious laughter, kind heart, and unwavering dedication to his loved ones, Timothy was a beloved figure in his community. Born and raised in a small town, Timothy grew up surrounded by the beauty of nature.Timothy Ferguson Case Pictures. Shanda Vander Ark Case Pics Timothy. Shanda Vander Ark Timothy Video. Shanda Vander Ark Story. Shanda Vander Ark Case Son. 3732. Likes. 241. Comments. 200. Shares. truecrimewithtonia. #greenscreen #shandavanderark #shandavanderarkcase #shandavanderarkguilty #shandavanderarkarrest #shandavanderarksentencing # ... Timothy ferguson case pictures, The woman at the centre of the sexting scandal that prompted the resignation of former Australian Test cricket captain Tim Paine has filed a sexual harassment claim against Cricket Tasmania in the ..., For Niall Ferguson, author of "The Ascent of Money," this is what happens when there is unregulated fundraising. Niall Ferguson, who wrote a seminal book on the history of money, h..., Timothy Ferguson 's birthday is 12/11/1954 and is 69 years old. Previously city included Palatine IL. Sometimes Timothy goes by various nicknames including Tim Ferguson, Timothy S Ferguson and T S Ferguson. We know that Timothy's political affiliation is currently a registered Republican; ethnicity is Caucasian; and religious views are listed ..., On July 6, 2022 at 6:37 a.m., responding officers from the Norton Shores Police Department found 15-year-old Timothy Ferguson deceased at this home. (Credit: Wood-TV), Paul Ferguson, 21, testified against his mother, Shanda Margaret Vander Ark, 44, about her “sadistic” murder of his brother, Timothy Ferguson, 15, but that cooperation did not carry enough weight with a Michigan judge on Monday to save him from a lengthy prison sentence. As referenced in court, Ferguson served as the “enforcer” while ..., Tim Ferguson (Photos), London, United Kingdom. 122 likes. This is defunct. Follow me here instead: http://fb.me/tim.ferguson.friend (It's just easier...), DeYoung said Timothy's cause of death was dehydration and malnutrition, and hypothermia was present as well. The manner of death was homicide. Prosecutors rested their case-in-chief. Shanda Vander Ark testified in her own defense, telling the jury that Timothy came to live with her in 2021 after previously living with her ex-husband., Shanda Vander, a 44-year-old lady, erected a trial suspect of torturing Timothy. He was her 15-year teen son. Timothy Ferguson’s body was found at their home in Michigan Norton Shores. Timothy Ferguson Photos. Timothy Ferguson, the young teen boy, was tortured by his mother and brutally killed., March 8, 2024 by megusta. Welcome readers to gokeylessvn.com! In this special article, we will take you deep into the heartbreaking case of Timothy Ferguson in Michigan through " Timothy Ferguson Michigan Photo Autopsy Report " We will analyze the content from the autopsy report in detail and sketch out actual images from this event. With ..., Paul Ferguson testifies in Shanda VanderArk's trial for killing his 15-year-old brother, Timothy. MUSKEGON, Mich. — The 21-year-old son of a Norton Shores mom who was convicted in the murder of ..., DeYoung said Timothy's cause of death was dehydration and malnutrition, and hypothermia was present as well. The manner of death was homicide. Prosecutors rested their case-in-chief. Shanda Vander Ark testified in her own defense, telling the jury that Timothy came to live with her in 2021 after previously living with her ex-husband., View the profiles of people named Timothy John Ferguson. Join Facebook to connect with Timothy John Ferguson and others you may know. Facebook gives..., The mother, Shanda Vander Ark, then instructed the eldest son, Paul Ferguson, to lie to police about how they discovered 15-year-old Timothy Ferguson and say the boy was on a “hunger strike ..., 631.6K Likes, 2.1K Comments. TikTok video from @Cosmic_theJelly (@cosmic_thejelly): "#ca #survivors #warriors #timothyferguson @". graphic picture of timothy ferguson. Woman vomits in court after seeing pictures of her son and the way she left him… Sentenced 50 to 100 years without probationoriginal sound - @Cosmic_theJelly., There, they found 15-year-old Timothy Ferguson dead. The home in Norton Shores where police say they found a 15-year-old dead of suspected abuse. (July 8, 2022), MUSKEGON, Mich. (AP) — A western Michigan woman convicted of murder and child abuse in the starvation death of a disabled 15-year-old son who weighed just 69 pounds was sentenced to life in prison without a chance of parole Tuesday.. Shanda Vander Ark, 44, of Norton Shores, found guilty in the July 6, 2022, death of Timothy Ferguson, was sentenced to an additional 50 to 100 years in prison ..., Timothy Ferguson Case Pictures. Timothy Ferguson Trial. Timothy Ferguson Crime Pics. 40.8K. Likes. 770. Comments. 272. Shares. courttvlive. 40.8K. 47.7K. Shanda Vander Ark was convicted of neglecting her 15 year old son Timothy Ferguson so severely he died in the basement of her home. She will be sentenced in January., Shanda Vander Ark had been accused of abusing her son, Timothy Ferguson, 15, who died in July 2022, weighing just 69 pounds, showing signs of malnutrition and hypothermia, WZZM reported, citing ..., 21.6M views. Discover videos related to Pictires of Timothy Ferguson Body on TikTok. See more videos about Paul Alexanders Body Now, Do You Recognize The Bodies Explained, Brian Shaw Bodybuilder, Brian Shaw Next to Bodybuilder, Stanley Starbucks Vs Pink Parade, Gypsyrose Welcome Home Video., @CrimeTok Shanda Sander Ark was found guilty of murdering her disabled son, 15-year-old Timothy Ferguson, whom she tortured and starved. Ark only fed him hot sauce soaked bread, deprived him of sleep & and would force him into ice baths. The teenager, who had autism and motor impairments, was made to sleep in a closet under the stairs and it’s …, timothy ferguson pictures texts offers 25 different styles with unique colors and designs, providing users with a variety of options to elevate their social media stories. To use this template, simply click the ""Use template"" button and you will be directed to the CapCut web with the template ready for editing., Timothy ferguson case pictures 940.87K uses, 25 templates - We are excited to introduce the " timothy ferguson case pictures " template, one of our most popular choices with over 940870 users. This template offers 25 different styles, providing users with a variety of options to create their perfect video., @CrimeTok Shanda Sander Ark was found guilty of murdering her disabled son, 15-year-old Timothy Ferguson, whom she tortured and starved. Ark only fed him hot sauce soaked bread, deprived him of sleep & and would force him into ice baths. The teenager, who had autism and motor impairments, was made to sleep in a closet under the stairs and it’s …, Shanda Vander Ark was found guilty of first-degree felony murder stemming from the death of her 15-year-old son Timothy Ferguson., Shanda Margaret Vander Ark, 44, appeared deeply distraught in court after being shown a picture of her dead son, Timothy Ferguson, 15, but prosecutors say it's her fault he ended up like that in ..., A western Michigan woman convicted of murder and child abuse in the starvation death of a disabled 15-year-old son who weighed just 69 pounds was sentenced to life in prison without a chance of parole Tuesday. Shanda Vander Ark, 44, of Norton Shores, found guilty in the July 6, 2022, death of Timothy Ferguson, was sentenced to an additional 50 to 100 years in prison for first-degree child ..., MUSKEGON COUNTY, MI – Timothy Ferguson laid lifeless inside a cold and dark closet known as his bedroom. His ribs, visible through the skin, showed signs of malnourishment. The 15-year-old boy ..., Timothy Ferguson autopsy photos are graphic images that document the injuries sustained by Timothy Ferguson, a 29-year-old black man who died in police custody in 2019. The photos were released to the public in 2021 after a protracted legal battle. The autopsy photos show that Ferguson suffered extensive injuries, including a fractured skull, a broken jaw, and numerous cuts and bruises., See Photos. View the profiles of people named Ferguson Timothy. Join Facebook to connect with Ferguson Timothy and others you may know. Facebook gives people the..., Paul Ferguson, 21, testified against his mother, Shanda Margaret Vander Ark, 44, about her “sadistic” murder of his brother, Timothy Ferguson, 15, but that cooperation did not carry enough weight with a Michigan judge on Monday to save him from a lengthy prison sentence. As referenced in court, Ferguson served as the “enforcer” while ..., Timothy Ferguson tenía algunas discapacidades mentales y estaba siendo educado en casa, dijeron los fiscales. El otro hijo de Vander Ark, Paul Ferguson, de 20 años, supuestamente participó en ..., Paul Ferguson, 21, pleaded guilty in December to first-degree child abuse in the death of 15-year-old Timothy Ferguson. He was sentenced Monday to a minimum 30 years and maximum 100 years in prison. Timothy, who had autism and was speech- and motor-impaired, weighed only 69 pounds when he died in July 2022 at the family's western Michigan ..., Shanda Vander Ark, 44, of Norton Shores, found guilty in the July 6, 2022, death of Timothy Ferguson, was sentenced to an additional 50 to 100 years in prison for first-degree child abuse. “I’ve been trying now for this entire case to wrap my mind around how somebody could do something so horrific, not only to another human being but to ...